The Best Braves Catchers of All Time: A Legacy Behind the Plate

Across a franchise history that spans three cities and more than 150 years, the Braves have put an extraordinary run of catchers behind the plate. A World Series folk hero in Boston. An eight-time All-Star and four-time Gold Glover in Milwaukee. A future Hall of Fame manager who could flat-out hit. A slugger who set the single-season home run record for catchers. A homegrown Georgia kid who made seven All-Star teams before he turned 30. And a modern group that caught a championship and is still adding to the story.

Tap up to three players below to build your ballot. Your first tap is your #1. Then cast your vote and share your ranking with Braves Country.

Behind the Plate: A Franchise History in Three Cities

Catcher is the only position on the field where the player faces the other way. It is the hardest job in baseball and the least generous one: the great ones squat ten thousand times a season, absorb foul tips off the mask, manage a pitching staff full of egos, and then get evaluated on their batting average. Braves history is unusually rich here. Boston, Milwaukee, and Atlanta each produced a catcher who would be the best in some other franchise's story.

Boston: Hank Gowdy and the Miracle

The first great Braves catcher belongs to the deepest part of the archive. Hank Gowdy was the everyday backstop for the 1914 "Miracle Braves," the team that sat in last place in July and finished by sweeping Connie Mack's Philadelphia Athletics in the World Series. Gowdy was the star of that Series, hitting well over .500 across the four games in one of the great performances of the dead-ball era. He is also remembered as the first major league player to enlist for service in World War I, and he later returned to the game as a coach. If your ballot rewards moments over volume, he belongs on it.

Milwaukee: Del Crandall Sets the Standard

Del Crandall debuted with the Boston Braves in 1949 and became the face of the position through the Milwaukee years, making eight All-Star teams and winning four Gold Gloves. He was the catcher for the 1957 World Series championship club, the one with Hank Aaron, Eddie Mathews, and Warren Spahn, and he was widely considered the best defensive catcher in the National League for most of a decade. Purists who weight defense and longevity tend to start their argument with Crandall and dare you to move him.

Right behind him came Joe Torre, who reached the majors with Milwaukee in 1960 and moved with the franchise to Atlanta in 1966. Torre could hit like a first baseman and catch like a catcher, making multiple All-Star teams and winning a Gold Glove in 1965. He was traded away before his 1971 MVP season in St. Louis, and of course went on to a Hall of Fame career as a manager, but the bat he swung in a Braves uniform was as good as any catcher the franchise has had.

Atlanta: Benedict, Olson, and the Bridge Years

The Atlanta era got quieter for a while. Bruce Benedict caught for the Braves from the late 1970s through the 1980s, made two All-Star teams, and was the steady presence behind the plate for the 1982 division winner. Then came 1990 and Greg Olson, an unheralded journeyman who made the All-Star team in his rookie year and caught the pitching staff through the worst-to-first summer of 1991. Olson's story is the kind of thing catchers specialize in: unglamorous, essential, and impossible to replace in the memory of anyone who watched it.

The Dynasty: Javy López and Eddie Pérez

Javy López arrived in 1992 and became the offensive standard for the position in Atlanta. He was a three-time All-Star, won the 1996 NLCS MVP, and was behind the plate for the 1995 World Series title. In 2003 he put together one of the great offensive seasons any catcher has ever had, hitting 43 home runs and setting the single-season home run record for the position at the time. Alongside him, Eddie Pérez became a beloved specialist, the personal catcher Greg Maddux trusted, and he won NLCS MVP honors in 1999. Between them they covered a decade of October baseball.

The Modern Era: McCann, d'Arnaud, and Murphy

Brian McCann is the homegrown answer. A Georgia kid drafted by his hometown team, he debuted in 2005, caught John Smoltz's staff, and made seven All-Star teams as a Brave while winning five Silver Sluggers. For most of a decade he was simply the best offensive catcher in the National League, and his return to Atlanta in 2019 to finish his career gave the story its bookend.

Then Travis d'Arnaud signed before the shortened 2020 season and turned into an October monster, catching the staff that won the 2021 World Series and adding an All-Star nod and a Silver Slugger along the way. Sean Murphy came over in a three-team trade before 2023, made the All-Star team in his first Atlanta season, and signed a long-term deal to keep the position in steady hands.

So Who Is the Best Braves Catcher of All Time?

The honest answer is that it depends entirely on what you value. If it's total production in a Braves uniform, McCann and Crandall are your finalists. If it's defense and reputation among pitchers, Crandall wins going away. If it's peak offense, nobody touches Javy López in 2003. If it's the biggest moment, it's Gowdy in 1914 or Eddie Pérez in 1999 or d'Arnaud in October 2021. And if it's the guy you'd want catching Game 7 tomorrow, that's a different list again.

That's the fun of it. Pick your three, cast your ballot, and go defend it.